Practice Opening:
“You play ball like a girl!” This used to be one of the worst insults of all time. In today’s day, it is quite a complement. Softball seemed as only the girl version of baseball. The girl’s who couldn’t compete with “the big guys,” played softball. That underhand pitch, the size of the field, how much bigger the ball is, seems easy. In reality, it just makes it harder. Recent studies shown us how much harder hitting a softball is than hitting an over-hand pitch of a baseball. The angle, speed, distance, and spin are just a few aspects of the windmill pitch’s difficulty. In reality, hitting a 95 mph, over-hand baseball pitch from 60 feet away is more difficult than hitting a 65 mph, windmill softball pitch from 43 feet away.
Practice Opening:
Has anyone ever really heard of a famous fast-pitch softball hitter? We hear about baseball homers all the time. The reason we don’t know about quality softball hitters is because there aren’t any. There are many more aspects about the windmill pitch that make it much more difficult than hitting an over-hand baseball pitch. The angle, speed, distance, and spin of the ball coming to the batter is completely different than baseball. The only true similarity of the two sports are the rules. Though people think softball is the easier version of baseball, it is not.
Purposeful Summary: Baseball vs. Softball: Which is Harder to Hit? by Kyle Odegard
We all know that softball is simply the “girl version” of baseball. The field is smaller, the ball is bigger, and the uniforms are quite different. Most believe that because of some of the few differences, this would make playing the game much easier. Girls are underestimated pretty often, but when it comes to softball, there is much empowerment. When baseball and softball get compared, most would always go into saying how much baseball is harder. The field is big, the ball is small and white, and the pitching is faster. All these descriptions are true, but it doesn’t make the sport any harder than softball.
Softball will never be harder than baseball, though the differences are important. Focusing on just the pitching, there are major aspects that make each sport unique. Baseball’s pitching style is an over hand throw to the strike zone. Due to this, the ball travels on a downward angle. The diameter of the ball is just under three inches. The distance from the pitching mound and home plate is 60 feet.
In softball the ball is much bigger. It is about three and a half inches in diameter. The pitcher’s mound is only 43 feet from home plate. Softball pitchers are known for their lever of an arm. They swing their arm over their head and flick the ball at their hip as fast as they can. Because of the low release point, the ball must travel up to past the strike zone.
The significance of these differences is how it changes the difficulty level. Due to the softball rise ball, and the batter natural movement of dropping the bat when swinging makes the batters percentage of hitting the ball productively go down tremendously. In softball, not only does the pitch rise, but it is also pitched at the distance of only 43 feet. That is only where the mound is placed. After the big leap off the mound and the intimidating windmill, the pitcher ends up about 38 feet away from the batter. This makes the reaction time to see the ball and to hit it super short.
Baseball’s pitching has only a few difficulties, but the main one is a size of the ball. Because of it’s small shape, the ball has a better chance of having movement. The pitcher can hold the ball a curtain way, and can make the ball do some crazy movements while approaching the strike zone. This makes the batter have to make sure the ball won’t be out of the strike zone by the time it gets there.
Quote Collection:
“From a physics point of view they differ only in details.” Alan Nathan, physics professor at Illinois.
“If you drop your hands to ht it, game over.” Tony Scoglio, professional baseball baseball/softball instructor.
“The best way to hit a rise ball is to take it.” Kyle Odegard
Purposeful Summary: The Great Debate: Baseball vs. Softball, Jen Yee
Hitting a ball coming at the strike zone at 65 mph causes the batter to see the ball so quickly that they need to have amazing hand-eye coordination. The ciliary muscles in the eye takes time to contract and relax to see an object far, to close. During a baseball or softball game, this has to happen super fast. Though that takes time, finding the ball in the air takes time too. During both kind of pitching, the ball is blocked by the pitchers body, therefor, the batter can’t see the ball until it is already in the air. This makes the eye muscles have to work even faster to see the ball and see it come closer.
To make this process quicker, the batter has to focus on a point in space that they assume the ball will come from. It can be easier to look at the pitchers release point. In baseball, this might be easier because the release point in next to their head, but in softball, the release point is by their hip.
Purposeful Summary: The Softer They Come. Why is it so hard to hit a softball? Rob Neyer
When focusing on the history of these sports, there are easy way to distinguish why softball can be harder. While comparing the sports in the Olympics, baseball teams score an average of 7.65 runs per game, while the softball team would score only an average of 3.8 runs. This could mean that the batters were unable to produce more solid hits of the pitchers to score more runs.
Softball pitchers like Jennie Finch and Lisa Fernandez are complete power players. Their 70 mph fastballs are as equal to mid 90s fastballs are in baseball. Both of these pitchers have a history of facing power MLB hitters. They both have almost a 100% success rate on striking them out. Of course baseball coaches had their players try to use the effective windmill pitching, but when they read to rule book, it is illegal in baseball. Softball is the only sport with this kind of motion.
Quotation Collection:
“When great players face off, softball is clearly a pitcher’s game.” Rob Neyer
“In softball, there are no famous hitters, only famous pitchers.” Rob Neyer
“1905 World Series, New York Giants legend Christy Mathewson tossed 3 shutouts allowing only 14 hits in 27 innings. That’s roughly what Finch, Fernandez and Osterman did these two weeks.” Rob Neyer
Purposeful Summary: Throw like a girl, Jennie Finch, pages 166-168.
While Major league is all professional and high tech, softball pitching effects baseball batters way differently than their average overhand throw. Jennie Finch is the most famous softball player in the world. She is a gold medalist and named Athlete of the Year in 2010.
She was asked to co-host Major League Baseball’s weekly show, “This Week in Baseball.” She was on the segment called Pinch, Hit, and Run with Jennie Finch. During this, she was challenged to pitch against a several dozen of major league batters. She has struck out over 35 hitter, including Mike Piazza and Albert Pujols. She could have faced more batters but they rather protect their reputation than get shown off by a girl. They didn’t want to go through that shame.
Purposeful Summary: Softball Pitch vs. Baseball Pitch (Youtube Video) by Egreensoftball
This video shows some test that were done to compare which kind of pitch has more force and difficulty level. The first test was to have one softball pitcher and one baseball pitcher to throw the ball at scientific gear that measures the ball’s impact. Baseball pitcher, Adam Jorgenson, pitched first. His 95 mph faseball created 2,411 pounds of force. Next was softball pitcher, Jennie Finch. Her 70 mph softball created the scientific gear to shatter and completely break the machine. This makes her pitch unmeasurable. In this first test, softball would be the winner here.
The next test was to pitch against a professional batter. Batter, Brain Byrne, hit 95 mph fastballs with no problem, though when it comes to the windmill fast pitch softball, it can’t be touched. This proves that even professionals have trouble with hitting a softball.
Next, they scientist went back to the computers. The measured all aspects of the baseball and softball pitches. From the distance, the speed, and the angle, the studied which pitch is harder to hit. After the measuring and the math, they stated that a baseball batter has .395 milliseconds to react to the pitch, while a softball batter has .350 milliseconds to react. This makes the softball batter have less time to think about the pitch, making it more difficult to make contact with the ball.
Lastly, Jennie Finch was tested in how she throws her pitches. She was decked up in motion capture technology to measure her movements. The state that her arm acts a 3 foot leaver for the ball. Because the ball is released at her hip, the ball must go high. This makes it harder for a batter to hit. Overall, these studies indicate that softball is the harder ball to hit.
Working Hypothesis:
A softball pitcher is harder to hit than hitting a baseball pitcher.
Working Hypothesis:
The aspects of hitting a softball are more difficult than hitting a baseball.
Counter Arguments:
- Professional baseball hitters are professional for a reason, they are supposed to know how to hit a 95 mph baseball pitcher. Because they have difficult hitting a softball, is because they don’t practice that as much as baseball. If they practiced hitting a softball the same amount of time they do to hit a baseball, their percentages of hitting the softball would go up.
- Hitting a softball and baseball are only harder when they are faster pitched. It makes hitting any ball harder when they are pitched over 95 and 65 mph.
- All players hit and see the ball differently, and that is hard to measure.