Causal Argument—TheAdmiral

The other day, I stumbled upon a quote by an unknown author that goes as follows; “There is no such thing as right or wrong, there is only cause and effect.” This quote speaks volumes in a society fueled by situations that quickly escalate because of social media. Social media gives a voice to the unheard, but the problem is that people are ready to condemn others without completely looking at every aspect of the situation.  There really is no such thing in this world as a right or a wrong thing to do; however, individuals have his or her own opinion about everything/ For example, Kaepernick’s decision to take a knee for the National Anthem. Right or wrong depends on one’s opinion and which side of the debate one chooses. Various people will have different opinions on the subject. As such, when debating the issue, answers from one side of the argument are thoughts that one may never contemplate and the same hold true for each counterargument. It seems counterintuitive that Kaepernick’s cause was just an effect of the problem of police brutality in America. The simple truth is, Kaepernick’s action was a single cause, that resonates major effects across America.

 

Outrage in mainstream America appears to be Kaepernick’s largest contribution to his argument. For generations, the playing of the national anthem has been a sacred ritual before many sporting events around the country. This anthem is not only to honor the country and the American flag, but a time to reflect and honor the service men and women that fight for freedoms at a time when Americans feel as much loss from war as World war II. Military families, both past and present, are insulted by Kaepernick’s kneeling. Even  the newly elected President of the United States, Donald J. Trump, issued a statement via twitter saying, “Very important that NFL players STAND tomorrow, and always, for the playing our National Anthem. Respect our Flag and our country!”.  The Commander in Chief also ordered the owners of NFL teams to dismiss any players that kneel for the Anthem.

In addition to the public outrage, NFL ticket sales and network rating s plummeted as confirmed by ticket sellers such as  Tickpick and TicketCity. As professional football transformed into an entertainment business with some sport sprinkled into it, the game changed from the rough and tough players heroes like Dick Butkus, Jack Lambert, Earl Campbell, Decan Jones, and company. People now atted NFL games to drink a few beers, relax with some family and friends, and watch tremendous athletes display their talents which are making big time plays and entertaining fans. Speaking with long time football enthusiast, Chuck Nucci, he explained that he does not want to watch the NFL when it is involved with politics. Nucci states, “I love football and I watch it for the love of the game. As soon as politics are involved, it’s not enjoyment anymore”. Many Americans feel the same as Nucci which explains the rapid decline in NFL ticket sales.

Like the NFL, collegiate football suffers from Kaepernick’s actions. Rowan University, along with other American colleges, now retain the players in the locker room until the national anthem is over. I have a personal experience as a football player; I would step onto the field, ready to hear the National Anthem and pay homage to our flag, country, service men and women only to find out the Anthem had already been played for the fans, and not for the players. Personally for me, the time before a game when I would hear the anthem was a time of great pride, and gave me chills. I would look at Old Glory waving in the wind, and think how thankful I was to play the great game of football in the greatest country in the world. “The Star- Spangled Banner” actually psyched me up as I prepared for “battle” as players and coaches call it. Many of my peers would often feel the same disappointment along with me, no matter the color of their skin, because the playing of the national anthem is a time to honor, not a time to protest.

Kaepernick’s kneeling was also an eye opener to a lot of people, including myself. I personally follow NFL news pretty closely, and I’m not sure if him not being able to find a job as an NFL quarterback has made bigger headlines than just NFL Network. Since Kaepernick decided to defy the only thing that everybody knew, which was standing for the National Anthem, he cannot find a job anywhere. No NFL team wants to bring him on the roster because he peacefully protested, which is his constitutional right to do. His protest might have been seen as “disrespectful to the servicemen and women,” but he did not make a mockery out of the Anthem like some players are doing now. Nobody wants to put their name out for Kaepernick, but they will for players like LeSean McCoy of the Buffalo Bills. McCoy was seen stretching, and absolutely making a mockery of the National Anthem, and the Buffalo Bills owner and staff had nothing to comment on the matter. This is a double standard, because both men did not participate in the National Anthem, but one did it peacefully, and one made a mockery out of the deal. If McCoy’s actions were not held against him and he is still employed, Kaepernick’s actions, and decision to take a knee and start a peaceful protest should not be held against him.

There have been many causes and effects that came from Kaepernicks decision to take a knee in the preseason game on August 26th, 2016, from outrage, to unemployment. Any way you slice it, Kaepernick made history with his actions, and with history there is going to be some sort of disagreement. Either way you look at it, either idolizing Kaepernick for his courage, or look down on him for his blatant “disrespect,” there is no such thing as right or wrong, there is only cause and effect.

Berr, Jonathan. “NFL National Anthem Protest Denting Ticket Sales.” CBS News, CBS Interactive, 29 Sept. 2017, http://www.cbsnews.com/news/nfl-national-anthem-protest-denting-ticket-sales/.

Branch, John. “Please Rise for Our National Anthem — If You’Re Not Too Busy.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 1 Oct. 2017, http://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/01/sports/football/nfl-anthem-protest.html.

Nucci, Chuck. Personal Interview 10, November 2017.

4 thoughts on “Causal Argument—TheAdmiral”

  1. Admiral, your first paragraph is 200 words of throat-clearing, the academic essay equivalent of “Testing 1 2 3.”

    I will distill it for you:

    If it’s true that there is no such thing as right or wrong, only cause and effect, then social media amplifies that one cause to the masses instantaneously. A single act can prompt millions of condemnations overnight, most of them uninformed, all of them highly opinionated. When Colin Kaepernick took a knee for the National Anthem, he wasn’t right or wrong until thoughtless millions chimed in with reactions that said more about themselves than whatever Kaepernick might have intended. Whatever led to Kaepernick’s brief demonstration of protest, his small action is still resonating.

    This version is less than half the length of the original but loses very little. And it’s still not a particularly good use of language because it doesn’t make a claim that matters.

    It easily could. And you’re not far from it.

    For example, you could use this paragraph to say that silent gestures gain all their power from their ambiguity. They mean what they mean to the viewer regardless of the intentions of the gesturer. They can be appropriated by many communities, each claiming a different meaning. The gesturer’s goal may have been clear in his head, but the repercussions that propagate outward from his small act take on not one life, but many lives of their own. CK could have SAID anything he wanted to in a pregame interview that fateful day, and his words would likely have accomplished little. But his near-blasphemous decision to apparently spite the flag and anthem was far more powerful. And radically more ambiguous. Pure as gesture, utterly adulterated as message.

    Twitter doesn’t care about the message as long as there’s activity. Conversation, conflict, and controversy keep the engine humming. When political speech is visual, it lends itself to meme, and memes are gold to social media. They eliminate analysis. They pretend to be thoughtful conclusions. They replace debate and careful consideration with slam dunks over their opponents’ head. The crowd goes wild and drowns out the opposition.

    That’s enough from me. Remember this:
    1. Make it clear and concise.
    2. Make it specific and lively.
    3. Replace stuff like this:

    As such, when debating the issue, answers from one side of the argument are thoughts that one may never contemplate and the same hold true for each counterargument.

    with stuff like this:

    Tweets are not debate; they’re mixed martial arts.

    Helpful? I’m here all day and night.
    I would appreciate your response.

    Like

  2. You need to own up to your own reactions here, TheAdmiral, more clearly than you have. You obviously don’t believe that “there is no right or wrong, only consequences.” You’re bitter that one man’s reckless action has led to a tangible loss in your life without benefiting you. You lost your pregame anthem. I feel for you. It’s a valid, valuable ritual. Your college is too timid to face any potential embarrassment, so they’ve taken the coward’s way out and kept you off the field. They don’t trust you to respect the flag.

    This is an academic essay. It needs to keep its own decorum. You don’t want to rant. But neither should you suppress your viable, pertinent, personal experience from your intellectual reaction. The subject matter of the course demands that you synthesize the two.

    Now, write this from the heart. The guy who said “there are only consequences” was trying to escape blame for doing something wrong.

    Are you up to it?
    I would appreciate your response.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s